Ashton Jeanty vs. Travis Hunter: The Case for the 2024 Heisman Trophy

Ashton Jeanty's explosive plays and consistent performance set him apart as the top Heisman candidate for 2024.

This year’s Heisman Trophy race has turned heads and sparked conversations like never before. With a two-way player and a Group of Five running back in the mix, the competition is fierce and filled with compelling narratives. Just take a look at the ballot: Colorado’s Travis Hunter and Boise State’s Ashton Jeanty are not just names; they represent a new era in college football where versatility and skill reign supreme.

Unique Contenders in the Heisman Race

Beyond Hunter and Jeanty, this year’s Heisman race features a plethora of intriguing stories. Miami’s quarterback, Cam Ward, began his journey at the FCS level, while Arizona State’s running back, Cam Skattebo, also shares a similar path. Oregon’s Dillon Gabriel is making waves at his third school, and Colorado’s Shedeur Sanders, the son of NFL legend Deion Sanders, is turning heads with his impressive play. Then there’s Penn State’s Tyler Warren, a tight end, who adds a rare twist to the Heisman conversation.

Every contender brings a unique narrative, but one player stands out for his remarkable consistency and excellence week after week. That player is Jeanty, who has not only put up jaw-dropping numbers but has also led his team to unprecedented heights.

Ashton Jeanty’s Heisman Resume

What makes Jeanty’s case for the Heisman so compelling? Let’s break it down:

  • 2,497 rushing yards
  • 7.3 yards per carry
  • 30 total touchdowns
  • 192.1 yards per game
  • No games under 125 rushing yards
  • 192 yards and 3 TDs against unbeaten Oregon
  • Boise State’s first College Football Playoff appearance

These numbers are not just impressive; they are historic. Jeanty’s performance has put him fourth in FBS history for rushing yards before his first playoff game.

Why Jeanty Deserves the Heisman Trophy

Historically, it has been rare for a player on a team with multiple losses to win the Heisman Trophy. Yet, recent winners like Caleb Williams and Jayden Daniels have shattered that narrative. They proved that the Heisman should go to the most outstanding player, regardless of the team’s overall success.

Jeanty embodies this philosophy. He has not only dominated on the field but has been the lifeblood of Boise State’s offense. When he missed a drive against Wyoming, the stark difference in performance was evident. The Broncos struggled without him, showcasing just how crucial he is to their success.

Opposing defenses have tried to contain Jeanty by stacking the box, but time and again, he has found a way to overcome the odds. With 2,497 rushing yards, Jeanty has never had a game with fewer than 127 rushing yards. That level of consistency is remarkable and speaks volumes about his talent and determination.

Comparing Jeanty to Past Heisman Winners

To put Jeanty’s achievements into perspective, consider the last running back to win the Heisman, Derrick Henry. Henry had five games with fewer than 100 rushing yards and averaged 5.6 yards per carry. In contrast, Jeanty has averaged an astounding 7.3 yards per carry. While it’s important to recognize that Jeanty has not faced the same level of competition as Henry did in the SEC, his accomplishments in the Mountain West are still impressive.

In fact, Jeanty made a statement against top-tier competition. He ran for 192 yards and three touchdowns in a narrow loss to unbeaten Oregon, a defense that stifled other elite players. Furthermore, in a championship game against UNLV, he rushed for 208 yards, proving he can perform under pressure.

The Case Against Other Contenders

While Hunter’s dual-threat capabilities are impressive, it’s essential to differentiate between being unique and being the most outstanding player. Hunter posted 1,152 yards and 14 touchdowns through the air, alongside a solid defensive performance with four interceptions. However, when compared to Jeanty’s staggering numbers and impact on his team, it becomes clear that Jeanty’s contributions are unparalleled.

Hunter’s two-way stardom is a rarity in college football, but could he have led Boise State to a 12-1 record? The answer is uncertain. Colorado finished with a 9-3 record, and while Hunter played a significant role, it’s fair to argue that Jeanty was the difference-maker for his team, propelling them to the College Football Playoff.

A Unique Heisman Race

If projections hold true, Hunter may become Colorado’s first Heisman Trophy winner in three decades. While his achievements are commendable, if the award is meant to honor the most outstanding player, it should go to Jeanty, who has redefined greatness at his position.

This year’s Heisman race is unlike any other, filled with remarkable stories and extraordinary performances. Jeanty’s journey has been one of dominance, consistency, and sheer talent. As we approach the announcement, it’s clear that the Heisman Trophy should reward not just versatility but also the player who has made an indelible impact on the game.

In a season filled with surprises and standout performances, one thing is certain: Ashton Jeanty has made a compelling case for college football’s most prestigious award.

X
Facebook
WhatsApp
Telegram

Today´s Best