Stephen A. Smith has stirred up the NFL conversation with his bold opinion on Patrick Mahomes. As the Kansas City Chiefs gear up for their chance at a historic third-consecutive Super Bowl win, Smith believes that if Mahomes leads his team to victory, he should be crowned the greatest quarterback of all time.
Mahomes is looking to threepeat this season, and there’s no denying that he is already on a trajectory to become one of the best quarterbacks in NFL history. With each game, he showcases his incredible talent, leadership, and ability to perform under pressure. But what would it mean for his legacy if he secures another championship?
Stephen A.’s Bold Claim
According to the First Take host, if Mahomes wins the Super Bowl this year, the debate about his greatness should be settled. “It would be epic, there’s no question about it. It’s never been done in the history of football,” Smith declared. He emphasized the significance of Mahomes achieving this feat in a league filled with extraordinary athletes and evolving strategies.
Smith elaborated on the challenges Mahomes faces, saying, “It’s still the most physical game out there, this is the National Football League. To be in this era with these outstanding athletes, the way the game has evolved with the kind of athletes you have to go up against to repeat… as a Super Bowl champion.” He pointed out the consistency of the Chiefs’ core, mentioning that it’s the same quarterback, tight end, head coach, and defensive coordinator leading the charge.
Smith’s argument hinges on the historical context of Mahomes’ potential achievement. “If you fail to do so and they win a threepeat, Tom Brady didn’t even win back-to-back-to-back Super Bowl titles,” he noted. This statement underscores the rarity of such an accomplishment in the NFL and positions Mahomes’ potential success as a monumental event for the sport.
Fan Reactions
However, not everyone is ready to anoint Mahomes as the GOAT just yet. NFL fans have taken to social media to express their thoughts on Smith’s assertion. One fan remarked, “It’s definitely something amazing and we’ll make him one of the greatest but not THE greatest.” Another added, “Still a little premature imo,” reflecting a sentiment that many share.
Some fans believe Mahomes must achieve more before being considered the greatest. “Pat has to win 8 to be the GOAT,” one user stated, while another pointed out, “Mahomes couldn’t even beat Brady in the playoffs, please. Only a conversation once he gets 7.” These comments highlight the ongoing debate about what it truly means to be the greatest quarterback in NFL history.
Statistical Comparisons
When comparing Mahomes to Brady, the numbers tell a compelling story. As of now, Mahomes has amassed **32,000 passing yards** and **245 touchdowns** in his career. In stark contrast, Tom Brady boasts an astonishing **89,000 yards** and **649 touchdowns**. Furthermore, Brady has won **seven Super Bowls** and **five Super Bowl MVPs**, while Mahomes currently holds **three** titles.
This statistical gap raises questions about the criteria for greatness. Is it solely about championships, or do individual statistics play a significant role? While Mahomes is undoubtedly talented, he still has a long way to go to reach the heights that Brady has established over his legendary career.
The Impact of a Three-Peat
Should Mahomes and the Chiefs achieve the unthinkable and win a third consecutive Super Bowl, it would not only be a monumental achievement for Mahomes but also for the franchise and the city of Kansas City. “It would be huge for the sport, it would be huge for the city, it would be huge for the franchise, and it would cement Patrick Mahomes as the greatest quarterback in the history of the National Football League,” Smith passionately stated.
This potential victory could shift the narrative around Mahomes and elevate him into a new stratosphere of NFL greatness. It would challenge the long-standing dominance of Brady in the GOAT conversation and could redefine how future generations view quarterback excellence.
Upcoming Championship Games
As the Chiefs prepare for their playoff run, fans eagerly await the upcoming championship games:
- NFC Championship Game: Washington Commanders at Philadelphia Eagles (Fox) – Sunday, January 26, 3 PM ET
- AFC Championship Game: Buffalo Bills at Kansas City Chiefs (CBS) – Sunday, January 26, 6:30 PM ET
With the stakes higher than ever, the NFL world will be watching closely to see if Mahomes can lead his team to another Super Bowl victory. If he does, the debate around his legacy will undoubtedly intensify, and fans will be left wondering just how high he can soar in the annals of football history.
As the season progresses, one thing is clear: the conversation surrounding Patrick Mahomes and his potential to be the GOAT is far from over. Whether he can achieve this remarkable feat remains to be seen, but the excitement surrounding his journey is palpable. Will he rise to the occasion and solidify his place in history? Only time will tell.
